Electric Toothbrushes – Gadget Show Test

The Gadget Show (Channel 5, Monday nights at 8pm) recently ran a review segment on electric toothbrushes. Following a pretty thorough test the joint winners were the Oral B Trizone 5000 and the Philips Diamond Clean.

As my family has owned both toothbrushes over the last few years there were a couple of points I wanted to add to the review that may affect your buying decision (if you follow the above links then you’ll see that I’ve left the same comments there too).

In the past we’ve had quite a few Oral Bs but we’ve always been disappointed with the battery life so when our current 5000 died we decided to opt for the Philips Diamond Clean.

The Philips Diamond Clean is considerably more expensive than the Oral B but looks better and feels nicer in the hand. It’s a definite premium product, the charging glass looks nice and the travel case is very sturdy and doubles as the charger (via USB).

However, there are two main downsides for us:

  • The heads do not have any means of differentiation so, in a family bathroom where the handle is shared, you need to ensure you keep your heads separate and remember whose is whose. The Oral B has small plastic coloured rings that snap onto the bottom of the brush head; a very simple, but effective idea.
  • The heads do not last very long. Apparently, they should last for three months but, after only six weeks of brushing twice a day for two minutes, the blue indicator bristles are now white and the bristles have started to splay out.
  • Both of these issues should be relatively simple for Philips to sort out but, at the moment, when the Diamond Clean battery finally gives up, we think we will return to the Oral B.

    Poppa G

    My Favourite Gadget

    It’s no secret that I love the iPad. The convenience, size and weight of this portable powerhouse are just perfect.

    At various times since owning one I’ve used it to read books, play games, work, connect remotely to other machines, shop, research and of course email. The form-factor have always meant that everything was a joy, except that on-screen keyboard!

    It’s not that bad but for an extended period of work I find it a bit awkward. Not only is there no haptic feedback (a little buzz to provide a sense that you’ve actually touched a key), it also covers a large chunk of the screen and can be difficult to use when the iPad’s in landscape mode and you’re holding it in both hands. Some iOS software tweaks have helped by allowing you to split the keyboard so it is closer to your thumbs on the side of the screen and also allowing you to move the keyboard around but it’s still not great.

    The iPad has Bluetooth. This allows you to pair with external keyboards but of course you don’t want to compromise portability by carrying a large keyboard around with you. A number of accessory providers started to build keyboard cases but these generally wrap around the iPad to work as a protective case, a stand and the required keyboard. A nice idea that will definitely appeal to some people but, to me, they just don’t fit in with the whole aesthetic of the iPad; you’re taking this sleek device and cocooning it in a tacky plastic/leather case that hides it completely and adds considerable bulk.

    Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover

    Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover

    So finally we come to my favourite gadget of the moment, the Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover. For me, this device ticks all the boxes. Not only does it function as an excellent keyboard (with a similar feel to standard Apple keyboards) but it is finished in brushed aluminium like the iPad and so when the two are joined together you have a highly portable package finished on both sides beautifully.

    The keyboard cover in use

    The keyboard cover in use

    The keyboard cover is very stable and comfortable to use. The iPad fits into an angled slot and is held in place using the inbuilt magnets along the edge. Although it’s designed to hold the iPad in landscape mode it is possible to use it with the iPad in portrait orientation but because there are no magnets in the base of the iPad to keep it in place you do need to ensure you’re using it on a stable base. Initially, it takes a bit of getting use to because rather than move the cursor with a mouse you touch the screen as normal with just the text entry part handled by the keyboard; it sounds obvious but is strange at first.

    All in all, I highly recommend this gadget. If you regularly send emails, surf the net or use the iPad for any sort of work then you won’t regret the initial outlay and you’ll wonder how you lived without it!

    Poppa G